« The Unthinkables | Main | How they see the world »

January 05, 2005

Wrong Mr. Stone!

Oliver Stone has recently tried to take advantage of the popular digust with conservatism in America and has claimed that his film, Alexander, flopped because of the fundamentalist reaction to the 'gayness' of Alexander!

First of all, Mr. Stone has given another reason for people to make fun of liberals and call them out of touch with reality. As a liberal, I have serious problems with that.

Then, whoever's fault it was, the market failure of Alexander was not the fault of fundamentalists! This is the same country in which Philadelphia, a movie about a gay person who is fighting for his rights, won an Academy Award and became very successful.

So, the problem is not with the already well known homosexuality of Alexander of Macedon or Mr. Stone's depiction of it. It is rather with the poor quality of the film itself. I am yet to see a person who thinks it is a good film.

Mr. Stone, next time, when you decide to make historical movies, do consider the history!

Posted by Khodadad at January 5, 2005 11:49 PM

Comments

Dear Khodadad,

I agree completely with this post. Oliver Stone's work is not bad as a whole, and he certainly understands American society and politics, and although his views on America may be contested, but no one can say that there he doesn't know what he is talking about.

It is a seriously problematic issue however, that everyone and their cousin think they can comment on matters that are beyond their area of research and understanding. You, Khodadad, can best atest to the fact that commenting on ancient history is not something one can do without years and years of loving, tough and dedicated research, particularly when one has no background in it.

But in the highly political atmospher of today's America, there is a race to blame one another of being neocons.
Along these lines, I read an article from Mr. Trita Parsi saying that Alexander of Macedonia was an archeotypical neocon.
But what I have tried to express for a while now is the fact that it is absolutely not true that one side of the American politial spectrum is good while the other side is evil, and in fact quite often those who have a reputation of being "liberals" and good guys and on the side of the mostaz'afin can in the final analysis be shown to be the most ethno and Euro-centric ones who tend uncritically to write off all that comes from our neck of the woods Euro-idealistically and with no sensitivity towards the specifics of what they try to fit into their generalized political theories...

Oliver Stone is in fact a committed liberal and has perhaps used his film to polemitically attack what he doesn't like, the shorthand for which everywhere seems to be "neocon." But through what he has produced, he has effectively shown that not all whom the kind hearted goody-goodies categorize as friends, do indeed respect others, as these others want to be respected.

Amir

Posted by: Amir at January 6, 2005 01:46 PM

I think that you are right, Khodadad, the failure of Alexander at the box office has nothing at all to do with the "gayness" of Alexander. Besides, only a minority of movie goers are fundamentalists. I am glad that you mentioned Philadelphia, it was a really excellent film. I am sure that Alexander's "gayness" had little to do with his historical accomplishments. If I understand the behavior of ancient aristocratic Greeks correctly, engaging in homosexual affairs was the norm for these men, not the exception. This being the case, Alexander's contemporaries probably did not perceive his behavior to be particularly abberant. I suppose that telling the story of Alexander should include some information about his private life, however, Mr. Stone should have placed this in the larger context of Alexander's role as a major force in ancient history and not made it a central theme of the movie.

Posted by: David at January 6, 2005 11:16 PM

Well said. Corny is the word to describe the movie.

Posted by: WhoMan at January 7, 2005 09:12 PM

I suppose that when you're high and mighty like Stone believes he is, you become a little less tolerable of criticisms and have a skewed vision of reality. Hollywood has a tendency to purport such visions.

Posted by: Jamak at January 8, 2005 04:31 AM

Stop premature ejaculation now with our premature ejaculation curehttp://premature-ejaculation.herbal-source.net

Posted by: premature ejaculation at February 7, 2005 09:09 PM

Hey

I agree with what you're saying. Thanks for sharing the info with us.

Posted by: webcam at March 3, 2005 08:43 PM

Good Point. Anyways, this was where i met her. You can join for free as well www.redtricircle.com

Posted by: click here at March 13, 2005 04:34 AM

Good Point. Anyways, this was where i met her. You can join for free as well www.redtricircle.com

Posted by: click here at March 13, 2005 10:23 PM

Omg thats right! Please come see me and my friends! ;)

Posted by: watch moi at March 18, 2005 02:34 AM

Omg thats right! Please come see me and my friends! ;)

Posted by: watch moi at March 18, 2005 07:07 PM

Come see me if you dare! Check me out on the w ebca m!

Posted by: free webcams at April 11, 2005 09:59 PM

enlarge your penis now using penis pills. only approved penis enlargement items to enlarge your penis. penis enlargement penis enlargement

Posted by: penis enlargement at April 28, 2005 07:26 PM

enlarge your penis now. penis enlargement safe. the best penis enlargement. penis enlargement penis enlargement

Posted by: penis enlargement at April 29, 2005 08:14 AM

diet pills. weight and fat loss. diet pills diet pills

Posted by: diet pills at April 30, 2005 03:06 AM

need a bigger penis? enlarge your penis now using penis enlargement items. safe penis enlargement. the best penis enlargement site. penis enlargement penis enlargement

Posted by: penis enlargement at May 1, 2005 11:03 AM

enlarge your penis now. penis enlargement safe. the best penis enlargement. penis enlargement penis enlargement

Posted by: penis enlargement at May 4, 2005 01:13 AM

enlarge your penis now using penis pills. only approved penis enlargement items to enlarge your penis. penis enlargement penis enlargement

Posted by: penis enlargement at May 5, 2005 04:03 AM

pms remedy. pms relief. pms relief

Posted by: pms relief at May 6, 2005 08:04 AM

play online poker for money now. the best online party poker game sites. online poker online poker

Posted by: online poker at May 7, 2005 09:24 AM

enlarge your penis now using penis enlargement pills. penis pills penis pills

Posted by: penis pills at May 10, 2005 08:19 AM

enlarge your penis now. penis enlargement safe. the best penis enlargement. penis enlargement penis enlargement

Posted by: penis enlargement at May 11, 2005 04:15 PM

diet pills. weight and fat loss. diet pills diet pills

Posted by: diet pills at May 13, 2005 05:02 AM

enlarge your penis now using penis enlargement pills. penis pills penis pills

Posted by: penis pills at May 13, 2005 06:09 PM

online dating sites. the best sites for online dating. adult dating. online dating sites online dating sites

Posted by: online dating sites at May 13, 2005 11:33 PM